Alpha Brain vs Magic Mind: Which is Actually Better?

Alpha Brain vs Magic Mind TL;DR Summary

While both Alpha Brain and Magic Mind have their merits, Magic Mind may hold an edge for individuals seeking an all-around boost to cognition and stress management, with its well-researched ingredient profile. However, those looking for a less expensive option (still very much expensive, though!) and a pill-based supplement might lean towards Alpha Brain, despite its usage of proprietary blends and some unproven ingredients.

What do we recommend?

-Click to See the Current Top 3 Nootropic Supplements-

About Alpha Brain and Magic Mind

Alpha Brain

Alpha Brain and Magic Mind are two popular nootropic options, though they come in different forms. Alpha Brain is a well-known nootropic supplement from the established American manufacturer, Onnit. It’s backed by celebrities and promises users improved memory, mental speed, and focus. Alpha Brain is an everyday dietary supplement that comes in capsule form, and a bottle typically lasts about a month and a half if you’re taking the recommended two capsules per day.

There is also Alpha Brain Instant available, which is a nootropic drink. It uses the same ingredients as Alpha Brain, it’s just different in terms of how you use it (capsules vs powdered drink).

Another version of Alpha Brain that you can find is Alpha Brain Black Label, which is totally different. For this particular comparison, we’ll focus on the original Alpha Brain.

Magic Mind

On the other hand, Magic Mind is marketed as the world’s first productivity shot. It was created by James Beshara, a bestselling author on nootropics, who developed the concoction as a healthier alternative to caffeine for managing stress and enhancing productivity. Magic Mind comes in a small drinkable form, each bottle containing a mix of beneficial ingredients. A packet consists of 15 bottles, intended to be taken daily for optimum benefits.

Ingredients

Now, let’s take a closer look at what’s inside these products.

Alpha Brain Ingredients

Alpha Brain uses a mix of vitamins and three proprietary blends to deliver its effects. Here’s a breakdown:

Vitamin B6 (as Pyridoxine HCI) 10 mg [1]
Onnit Flow Blend™ 650 mg: L-Tyrosine, L-Theanine, Oat (straw) Extract, Phosphatidylserine
Cat’s Claw (Uncaria tomentosa) (bark) 350 mg [2]
Onnit Focus Blend™ 240 mg: Alpha glycerylphosphorylcholine (Alpha GPC), Bacopa (Bacopa monnier) (aerial parts) Extract (100 mg), Toothed Clubmoss (Huperzia serrata) (whole) Extract [Standardized to 1% Huperzine A, 400 mcg]
Onnit Fuel Blend™ 60 mg: L-Leucine, Pterostilbene

The problem with proprietary blends is that it’s impossible to know the exact dosages of each ingredient. Also, there is a concern that some ingredients, like Oat Straw, are unproven as nootropics.

Magic Mind Ingredients

Magic Mind also contains a range of ingredients. However, they’re hidden in a patented proprietary blend, making it difficult to determine the exact dosages. Here’s a list of its components:

Magic Mind Nulixir Patented Blend: Olive Oil, Matcha, Organic Ashwagandha, Bacopa Monnieri, Rhodiola Rosea, Choline, Echinacea, Chlorophylin (as Sodium Copper Chlorophyllin], Turmeric, Organic Lion’s Mane, Phosphatidylserine, Organic Cordyceps, L-Theanine, Organic Natural Caffeine, Vitamin C (as Ascorbic Acid), Sea Salt, Vitamin B3, Saffron, Piperine, Vitamin B2, Organic Vitamin D3, Vitamin B12
Other Ingredients: Filtered Water, Organic Agave, Organic Ceremonial Grade Matcha, Natural Flavors, Potassium Sorbate (to preserve freshness).

The caffeine content in each bottle is 55 mg. [3]

While Magic Mind doesn’t share the precise quantities of its ingredients, they do make it clear that their product contains some well-known nootropics, including Ashwagandha, Bacopa Monnieri, Rhodiola Rosea, and Lion’s Mane, along with other beneficial ingredients.

The critical takeaway is that both supplements have beneficial ingredients, but the lack of transparency with their dosages due to proprietary blends could be a concern for some. [4] You should experience some degree of benefit if they are dosed correctly. Even then, neither Alpha Brain nor Magic Mind are among the most effective brain performance formulas we’ve seen.

Which Ingredient Formula Looks Better?

When it comes to the ingredient formula, Magic Mind appears to have an edge over Alpha Brain, despite both supplements featuring proprietary blends that obscure the exact quantities of ingredients.

While both supplements contain some similar ingredients, such as Bacopa Monnieri and L-Theanine, which are well-known for their cognitive enhancing properties, Magic Mind has an impressive list of well-researched ingredients. It includes Rhodiola Rosea and Lion’s Mane, which are recognized for their mental health benefits.

In contrast, Alpha Brain contains a few ingredients like Oat Straw and Cat’s Claw, which are unproven as nootropics. The thought experiment of everyone eating oats experiencing cognitive benefits highlights the skepticism around the effectiveness of these ingredients.

Customer Reviews

Both supplements enjoy largely positive customer reviews, attesting to their popularity and effectiveness. However, the detailed negative reviews shouldn’t be ignored either.

Alpha Brain has a rating of 4.1/5 stars on Amazon, which, while decent, is not overwhelmingly positive. Some users have reported improvements in focus and cognitive function, while others experienced side effects or didn’t notice any benefits.

Magic Mind, while not listed on Amazon, also has many glowing reviews on its website from satisfied customers praising its efficacy in boosting energy and focus. However, without access to independent review platforms, it’s difficult to evaluate the range of experiences or potential downsides.

Pricing

Alpha Brain is priced at $79.95 for a one-time purchase of a bottle containing 90 capsules, enough for 45 days at the recommended dosage. There is an option to subscribe for a regular delivery that provides a slight discount.

Magic Mind, on the other hand, is significantly more expensive upfront, with a packet of 15 bottles costing $111. However, the price drops to $59.25 per packet (which equates to $3.95 per bottle) for those subscribing for regular delivery. Considering the suggested daily intake, this would last for 15 days. Thus, the cost is something to consider for potential long-term use.

Final Word

Both Alpha Brain and Magic Mind offer potential cognitive benefits, and which one to choose largely depends on individual preferences, including form (capsule vs. drink), pricing, and ingredient transparency. However, it appears that despite less ingredient transparency, Magic Mind may offer a more compelling formula due to the well-researched nature of its ingredients compared to Alpha Brain.

Keep in mind, though, it’s essential to consult with a healthcare provider before starting any new supplement regimen, particularly if you have any pre-existing health conditions or are taking other medications.

Not what you were looking for?